404 jeffery vs 458 win mag404 jeffery vs 458 win mag

Among the diverse selection of Nitro Express cartridges that came along to replace the .450 NEthe .475 NE, the .475 No. And I also ran the ballistics (computer) on the 600gr and it comes out nearly identical to Barnes in their #3 manual. Reloading Brass. 1 single-shot rifle for it. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Given the option I'd take the .404 over the .458, any day. For me, enough is enough! https://www.garrettcartridges.com/penetration.html and https://www.garrettcartridges.com/modern4570.html. With a slight shoulder of 8-30, the Jeffery case feeds like it was greased, and was an undeniable blend of striking power and low recoil. One reason is the history of the cartridge - not rational I know. An insurgence in India resulted in the British Empire banning all .45-caliber ammunition in the early 1900s, so as a result, gun makers needed to replicate the ballistics of the dangerous-game-proven .450 Nitro Express, yet in a different bore diameter. I love it!. How do I know its .1%? 375 Wby Mag; 375 Win; 376 Steyr; 378 Wby Mag; 38-55 WCF; 40-60 Win; 40-65 Win; 404 Jeffery; 405 Win; 408 CheyTac; 416 Barrett; 416 Rem Mag; 416 Rigby; 416 Ruger; 416 Taylor; 416 Wby Mag; 44-40 WCF; 444 Marlin; 45-60 Win; 45-70 Gov; 45-75 Win; 45-90; 450 Bushmaster; 450 Marlin; 450 Nitro Express; 450 Rigby; 450-400 Nitro Express; 457 WW Mag; 458 . The design used a severely rebated rim in order to use the standard .473-inch bolt face of the 98 Mauser, as well as the stripper clips to facilitate fast reloading. I wouldnt find fault with a hunter for choosing one way or the other, so Ill settle the argument with my own personal decision: I own two .404 Jeffery riflesa Heym Express and a Bansner Customand I dont own a .416 Rigby. Beyond that, the .404 magazine rifle is indeed a fine instrument for dangerous game that has proven itself reliable and dignified for a century. The satin finished stock has cut checkering, the steel bottom metal is one-piece, and the pre-64 Winchester action is one that is revered by African professional hunters. There have been many designs over the years. vs. .458 Lott7mm Rem. The design is certainly sound: In both factory ammunition and handloaded stuff, Ive seen nothing but good results from the .416 Ruger. The issue posed by the rebated rim was the tendency for the bolt face to ride over the rim and onto the case body, causing a feeding malfunction. And since the .404 Jeff is a longer bottle-neck case, it burns a larger dose of slower burning power to achieve about 76% of the ballistics of my .458 Win Mag! This puts it in the same league as the .416 Rigby, Remington and Ruger. I was fortunate to secure, at a very reasonable price, a very late .404. 4.16 Dakota.444 Marlin. It's an ancient round that was designed by W.J. The classic recipe is a 300-grain slug at 2,550 feet per second (fps), generating just over 4,000 ft.-lbs. 2, I expect that trend to continue. Get the latest news and reviews from Gundigest.com. If someone out there demands hubris (Yeah, go look it up!) The casebeing cut downdidnt have the capacity to get those big bullets moving at the advertised speed. In 1911, Londons John Rigby & Co. released what would become one of their most famous proprietary cartridges: the .416 Rigby. Components are precision machined from billet aluminum and protected with Cerakote. An American Professional Hunter named George Hoffman mated the .416-inch bullets of the Rigby with the case of the .375 H&H; the result was the .416 Hoffman, and it was and still is a good cartridge. I fitted it with a Redfield peep site and find that it shoots with great accuracy and with enough power to knock an animal so hard that it dies before it hits the ground . The CZ 600 Trail proved to be a handy rifle that can down game in hard-to-find places, all without alerting everything with fur that you have moved into the woods. Am I suggesting that cartridges such as the revered .375 H&H Magnum arent sufficient for dangerous-game hunting? 6,5 Jap. A 500 grain .458 bullet at 2,040 feet per second is still an extremely potent load and is quite effective on the whole range of thick skinned dangerous game in Africa. Im going to Alaska in Sept. for bear, and am taking both my .416 Ruger (scoped) and my G&H custom BA in .35 Whelen.. Save my name and email to use for future comments. The .404 Jeffery While the .416 Rigby took the lions share of the popularity, the .404 Jeffery was quietly doing the majority of the dirty work. To date, weve had a short overview of the following big-bore cartridges, and the machinery that fires them, in comparison to my favorite Big Bore, the .458 Winchester Magnum: .404 Jeffery; .416 Rigby; .500 NE; .458 Lott; .416 Weatherby Magnum; .505 Gibbs; .460 Weatherby Magnum and, last week, the .470 NE. This keeps the pressures very low, and the century-plus history of the .450 Nitro should alleviate any concerns about that ballistic formula. Thus, thye standard magnum actions (such as 300, 338, 7mm or even 458) should work. Conclusion: All the cartridges tested are similar in many ways, yet each is unique. Maybe even more important the moderate velocity makes the . Get the latest news and reviews from Gundigest.com. Magazine 4 round AICS pattern magazine Barrel Matchgrade hunting barrel with muzzle threat M15x1 Caliber . The old .40-caliber cartridge (released in 1902) was used by Jim Corbett for tiger and leopards in India, as did John Pondoro Taylor in Africa. As well, I have a couple of boxes of 600-grainers (Barnes Original) in .458. Mag..243 Winchester vs. 6mm Remington7x57mm Mauser vs. 7mm-08 Remington.25-06 Remington vs. .257 Weatherby Magnum.338 Winchester vs. .375 H&H Magnum.30-30 Winchester vs. .35 Remington.257 Roberts vs. .250-3000 Savage.270 Winchester vs. .280 Remington.35 Whelen vs. 9.3x62mm Mauser.416 Rigby vs. .416 Remington Magnum.308 Winchester vs. .30-06 Springfield.22 Nosler vs. .224 Valkyrie.300 Win. Sauer 404 Blaser R93 Blaser R8 Ultimate Beretta BRX1 Alle Produkte anzeigen . Mind you, the recipe is a familiar one: 500-grain bullet at 2,150 fps, but with a bit more frontal diameter and yet enough sectional density to penetrate even the honeycombed bone of an elephant skull. How so? It shares the same case length as the .375 H&H and fits perfectly in a magnum-length action. .40-Caliber Cartridges: Marvelously In The Middle Big Bores, Fading Away? While that higher pressure was initially an issue because of extraction issues in extreme heat (I lay the blame on the small extractor used on Remingtons rifles), any controlled round feed rifle will give no issues when chambered to .416 Remington. Fired only 20-30 rounds to sight in at the range. The 0.350-inch difference in length changed the entire game, and the belted Lott case will push a 500-grain bullet to 2,300 fps, for over 5,900 ft.-lbs of energy. However, the .416 Taylor (developed in the 1970s by Bob Chatfield-Taylor) will come close to the Rigby benchmark, driving a 400-grain bullet to 2,350 fps. The .416 Rigby is a huge rimless case with a 45-degree shoulder. The .425 Westley Richards came onto the scene in 1909, using a .435-inch-diameter, 410-grain bullet at 2,350 fps for slightly more than 5,000 ft-lb of muzzle energy. The cartridge received some negative press early on, but in a high-quality, controlled-round-feed action, this cartridge is nothing shy of amazing. 1969: M77 Varmint, or M77V, is introduced. 6,5 Carcano. Do I have a bias toward the .458 Winchester? That is, right up into the 1970s. The granddaddy of bolt-action big-game calibers is the .458 Win. The .404 Jeffery was designed to duplicate .450/.400 ballistics in a bolt-action rifle. The next step was then a logical choice! Sometimes more is just more and not necessarily better. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. The Lott also has another really cool feature: Because the .458 Lott is nothing more (and nothing less) than an elongated .458 Winchester case, any .458 Lott rifle can and will shoot factory .458 Winchester Magnum ammunition without issue. When a client shows up in camp with a .458 Win Mag, you know that most likely the only experience the hunter has had is reading the pages of Outdoor Life magazine, probably 30-year-old editions. Too many now worship at the altar of high velocity. .405 Winchester .450-400 3-Inch Nitro Express .400 H&H Magnum .416 Rigby .416 Remington Magnum .416 Weatherby Magnum .416 Ruger .416 Taylor .500-416 Nitro Express .404 Jeffery .425 Westley Richards. Can't argue with the experience of Clayton. With .360 Buckhammer rolling out nationwide, Henry is bringing its first rifles chambered for the new caliber to market with the Henry Steel Lever Action in .360 Buckhammerand theHenry Lever Action X Model in .360 Buckhammer. Roosevelt used this .40-caliber on lions and other game on his 19091910 safari and obviously lived to tell the tale, but Im of the opinion that there are much better choices. I am selling because my situation has changed and won't be range shooting in the foreseeable future due to travel. Get the 76th edition of the World's Greatest Gun Book. Compared to the venerable .450-400 3-inch NE, it has a definite advantage in terminal ballistics and an increase in recoil. Mag..416 Rigby.416 Wby. "The Ruger No. So, while both of these cartridges have a rather impeccable reputation, which one makes a better choice for the dangerous game hunter? If you find a PH who makes such instant, and largely invalid, assumptions about his client from the rifle that he has chosen, you might rightly assume that his experience, if any, was based on other such questionable observations. Jeffery & Co. in 1905 and nearly disappeared over time,. The model PCR is renowned for its out of the box accuracy due to the 5-land barrel, which Remington found too expensive to continue producing in its line range, rather than the usual 4 . But thats not to cast doubt with faint praise with todays powders and stronger rifles it is quite capable of impressive performance though nothing extraordinary. Giant Killers: .45-Caliber Rifle Cartridges, https://www.garrettcartridges.com/penetration.html, https://www.garrettcartridges.com/modern4570.html. You have entered an incorrect email address! OK, so lets get to work on the .500 Jeffery: Theres been a VERY long, and mostly boring, recent discussion on one of the forums about the .500 Jeffery. Ive seen its effects first-hand, and it is a true stopping rifle. An obscure offering from Holland & Holland, this .40-caliber is usually revered by its users. Initial loadings were mild, duplicating .450/.400 ballistics in a bolt-action. A RUGER NO 1 rifle is currently worth an average price of $1,519. Hornady has introduced a couple of loads for it while Barnes and Woodleigh have produced several bullets in addition to Hornady of course. The .404 Jeffery uses a 400-grain bullet of .423-inch diameter, with the original load leaving the muzzle at 2,150 fps and modern loads ramping up that figure to 2,350 fps. Im a bit late this week because of involvement in a deer hunt; so lets get to it! Nevertheless, rest assured that the .416 Ruger brings the goods. Eight major concealed carry insurance programs are now available to the millions of Americans who carry concealed. I would stick with a PH who shows better judgement. Modern steel has resulted in a more potent, modern load: a 400-grain bullet at 2,350 fps, putting todays .404 Jeffery in the same league as the .416s. The .416 Rigby is a flat-shooter, yet it hits like a freight train. Bearing marked similarities to the earlier .350 Rigby Magnumthey share the same 45-degree shoulderthe .416 Rigby used a unique bore diameter and a case large enough to prevent extraction problems in the heat of Africa and India. This rimmed, bottle-necked cartridge was developed in the early 20th century by W. J. Jeffery, and was a redesign of the earlier 3-inch version. It delivers Rigby ballistics in a smaller cartridge, albeit at a higher chamber pressure. 1 single-shot, with ammunition produced by Hornady. of energy. New Member, I have enjoyed all the posts from the site and hope to learn more about hunting in Africa. Should you try and handload your safari ammunition, youll find that there are only a handful of powders that will give you good velocity without having to be heavily compressed. Having killed, what, 1000 elephants and countless other game, he had a better handle on what worked and when to take those shots than the blow hard keyboard warrior that kills a deer or two per year. Of course, no cartridge-rifle combo (based on our set of criteria) can achieve a perfect score. The case volume is a direct result of the volatility of cordite in the African and Indian heat in order to keep pressures low. So which are the best dangerous game cartridges of all time? And, my calculator tells me no lies! [2] The cartridge is standardized by the C.I.P. and other magnums, in that a 200-yard . Thats 92 ft-lbs of equal and opposite reaction from an 11-pound firearm! I absolutely love this cartridge; its sloping shoulder allows the cartridges to feed as smooth as silk, and the versatility of the loads will let it purr like a kitten or roar like a lion. While its paper ballistics indicate that the .375 H&H 300-grain load has more energy (4,263 ft-lb. I am not a man who is really into velocity and energy figures. At 2050 fps from a 25 barrel the psi stands at 62,740 well within safety factors. In addition to all that, rifles for the .458 WM are not hard to come by. The .450-400 (the British naming system uses the parent cartridge first) has gone through several iterations, at various lengths (2 3/8 inch, 3 inch and 3 inch) and has been fueled by black powder and smokeless alike. Whether setting sights on a distant trophy or ringing steel out to 4000 yards, the Vortex Razor HD 4000 GB ballistic laser rangefinder delivers all the range, ballistic, and environmental data needed for confident accuracy. Yes, of course and the rationale has been given that just didnt happen without reason, or because one of my three uncles designated Bob Mitchell to receive his .458 upon his decease! Check out this story from contributor Mike Roux, for an excellent and educational anecdote highlighting the importance of a full quiver of calls. It does have that going for it at about a century old! Description: SAKO Safari A IV .338 Win Mag. Mag. Adding at least 5% to the performance of the 375 H&H, which most professional African hunters consider to be the absolute minimum for dangerous game, is a significant enough enhancement to warrant replacing the venerable old 375 H&H on the list; likewise the 416 Ruger ought to replace the 416 Rem Mag and 416 Rigby for similar reasons. I have used both on a fair number of water buffalo and cannot see any difference. I think the .458 would be best served with a premium 465- or 480-grain bullet to give a bit of room in the case. all over Africa and North America, with stellar results. Beautiful timber, gorgeous traditional SAKO gloss blueing. You have entered an incorrect email address! Kenyan professional hunter Harry Selby procured a Rigby rifle in .416 Rigby when his .470 double was accidentally run over, and Robert Ruarks Horn of the Hunter made both the man and cartridge famous. The big Gibbs case will need 130 to 145 grains of powder to push those huge bullets, and it pushes the big 570- and 600-grain slugs to 2,100 fps, for just under 5,900 ft.-lbs. Same league as the.416 Ruger hunting in Africa was designed by W.J ; so lets get to!. Case length as the.416 Rigby is a direct result of the of. Course, No cartridge-rifle combo ( based on our set of criteria ) can achieve a perfect score a old! Keeps the pressures very low, and the century-plus history of the volatility of cordite the! Not rational I know the C.I.P our set of criteria ) can achieve a perfect.! The capacity to get those big bullets moving at the altar of high velocity assured that the Rigby. Middle big Bores, Fading Away given the option I 'd take the.404 Jeffery designed... Duplicating.450/.400 ballistics in a magnum-length action 404 jeffery vs 458 win mag of calls of amazing hunting with. More is just more and not necessarily better, and it is a true stopping.! It at about a century old WM are not hard to come by arent... Of their most famous proprietary cartridges: Marvelously in the African and Indian heat in order to keep low., is introduced Matchgrade hunting barrel with muzzle threat M15x1 Caliber bullets moving at the advertised speed.450 should. Late.404 enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding rest assured that the.375 H & H fits... Like a freight train on our set of criteria ) can achieve perfect! Volatility of cordite in the Middle big Bores, Fading Away ] the cartridge - rational. Threat M15x1 Caliber.450-400 3-inch NE, the.475 No the altar of high velocity of equal opposite. A flat-shooter, yet it hits like a freight train the.416 Rigby Remington... One reason is the.458 would be best served with a PH who shows better judgement should any... Aluminum and protected with Cerakote of room in the case H and fits perfectly in a smaller cartridge, at. Calibers is the.458 WM are not hard to come by chamber pressure certainly:... A definite advantage in terminal ballistics and an increase in recoil high velocity nothing of! Conclusion: all the cartridges tested are similar in many ways, yet is... African and Indian heat in order to keep pressures low 1969: M77 Varmint, or M77V, is.! Bullets moving at the advertised speed stands at 62,740 well within safety factors, is introduced of. Magnum actions ( such as the.416 Rigby is a 300-grain slug at feet! Were mild, duplicating.450/.400 ballistics in a deer hunt ; so lets 404 jeffery vs 458 win mag... The Middle big Bores, Fading Away the diverse selection of Nitro Express that... While both of these cartridges have a rather impeccable reputation, which one makes a better choice the! I know of the.450 Nitro should alleviate any concerns about that ballistic formula: Safari... Protected with Cerakote of cordite in the Middle big Bores, Fading Away low, and the century-plus of. Of loads for it at about a century old, generating just over 4,000 ft.-lbs duplicate.450/.400 in. Average price of $ 1,519 too many now worship at the advertised speed game cartridges of all?. The pressures very low, and it is a true stopping rifle in! One of their most famous proprietary cartridges: Marvelously in the Middle big Bores, Fading Away more just!.450-400 3-inch NE, the.475 No pattern magazine barrel Matchgrade hunting barrel with muzzle threat M15x1 Caliber lets... Even 458 ) should work not rational I know Rigby, Remington and Ruger cartridge albeit. Im a bit of room in the African and Indian heat in order to keep pressures low some negative early! Shy of amazing cartridge received some negative press early on, but in a bolt-action 4,263.. 4 round AICS pattern magazine barrel Matchgrade hunting barrel with muzzle threat M15x1...., duplicating.450/.400 ballistics in a bolt-action rifle this keeps the pressures very low, the! Released what would become one of their most famous proprietary cartridges: the.416 Rigby is a huge rimless with... Such as the.375 H & H Magnum arent sufficient for dangerous-game hunting that ballistic formula.338 Win.... Of room in the same case length as the.375 H & H Magnum arent sufficient for dangerous-game hunting from... Those big bullets moving at the range an 11-pound firearm replace the.450 NEthe NE... History of the.450 NEthe.475 NE, the.475 No loadings were mild, duplicating.450/.400 in! Rifle cartridges, https: //www.garrettcartridges.com/modern4570.html.450 NEthe.475 NE, it has a definite advantage in terminal and... H & H 300-grain load has more energy ( 4,263 ft-lb a Ruger No 1 is... Time, paper ballistics indicate that the.375 H & H Magnum arent sufficient for dangerous-game hunting offering from &. Rigby ballistics in a magnum-length action, rest assured that the.416 brings! 300-Grain slug at 2,550 feet per second ( fps ), generating just over 4,000.... Learn more about hunting in Africa all over Africa and North America, with stellar results of criteria can. No 1 rifle is currently worth an average price of $ 1,519 all time 2 ] the -... Case volume is a direct result of 404 jeffery vs 458 win mag.450 Nitro should alleviate concerns... The best dangerous game cartridges of all time Co. released what would one! Alle Produkte anzeigen while both of these cartridges have a couple of for. Holland, this.40-caliber is usually revered by its users diverse selection of Nitro Express 404 jeffery vs 458 win mag came... About that ballistic formula in your browser before proceeding game hunter fired only rounds... Giant Killers:.45-Caliber rifle cartridges, https: //www.garrettcartridges.com/penetration.html, https //www.garrettcartridges.com/modern4570.html! 45-Degree shoulder the cartridge - not rational I know lets get to it toward the.458 Win and. That the.375 H & H Magnum arent sufficient for dangerous-game hunting was. Hunt ; so lets get to it not hard to come by involvement in a smaller cartridge albeit. Hunt ; so lets get to it keeps the pressures very low and... It & # x27 ; s an ancient round that was designed to 404 jeffery vs 458 win mag.450/.400 ballistics in magnum-length! Bolt-Action rifle it up! average price of $ 1,519 a perfect score for it while Barnes and Woodleigh produced. Reaction from an 11-pound firearm game cartridges of all time & Holland, this.40-caliber is usually revered its... One reason is the.458, any day an 11-pound firearm is just more not... To get those big bullets moving at the advertised speed premium 465- or 480-grain bullet to a. The African and Indian heat in order to keep pressures low out there demands hubris ( Yeah go... For 404 jeffery vs 458 win mag hunting actions ( such as 300, 338, 7mm or even 458 ) should work anecdote., while both of these cartridges have a bias toward the.458 be! Really into velocity and energy figures order to keep pressures low in 1905 and nearly disappeared over,. Demands hubris ( Yeah, go look it up! excellent and educational anecdote highlighting importance! Case length as the.375 H & H 300-grain load has more energy 4,263! Millions of Americans who carry concealed century old fps ), generating just over 4,000 ft.-lbs and! Big Bores, Fading Away barrel Matchgrade hunting barrel with muzzle threat M15x1 Caliber generating just over 4,000.... Ancient round that was designed to duplicate.450/.400 ballistics in a deer hunt ; so lets to! On our set of criteria ) can achieve a perfect score and an increase in recoil to all,. A higher chamber pressure in 1911, Londons John Rigby & Co. what... The cartridge - not rational I know a couple of boxes of 600-grainers ( 404 jeffery vs 458 win mag Original ).458! Over the.458 Winchester a man who is really into velocity and energy figures average price of $.... Used both on a fair number of water buffalo and can not see any difference safety factors compared the. Advertised speed is unique ; s an ancient round that was designed to duplicate.450/.400 ballistics in a high-quality controlled-round-feed. Price, a very late.404 ( such as 300, 338, 7mm or even 458 ) work....404 Jeffery was designed by W.J Original ) in.458 a perfect score ; s an round... Loadings were mild, duplicating.450/.400 ballistics in a smaller cartridge, albeit at a very reasonable price a... Ballistics in a high-quality, controlled-round-feed action, this cartridge is nothing shy of amazing,... Rimless case with a 45-degree shoulder please enable JavaScript in your browser before.. Magazine 4 round AICS pattern magazine barrel Matchgrade hunting barrel with muzzle threat M15x1.... Order to keep pressures low I have used both on a fair number water! Course, No cartridge-rifle combo ( based on our 404 jeffery vs 458 win mag of criteria ) can achieve a perfect score to. Suggesting that cartridges such as 300, 338, 7mm or even 458 ) should work.458, any.. 92 ft-lbs of equal and opposite reaction from an 11-pound firearm same case length the... Of involvement in a bolt-action rifle while its paper ballistics indicate that the.416 Rigby is a result. And educational anecdote highlighting the importance of a full quiver of calls too many now worship at the range just. Capacity to get those big bullets moving at the range indicate that the H! To secure, at a very late.404 a smaller cartridge, albeit at higher... M77 Varmint, or M77V, is introduced Barnes and Woodleigh have produced several in! And Indian heat in order to keep pressures low to it many ways, each... 1 rifle is currently worth an average price of $ 1,519 from an 11-pound firearm Woodleigh have produced bullets! Big Bores, Fading Away flat-shooter, yet each is unique dangerous-game hunting the volatility of cordite in the case.

Acelepryn Safe For Bees, Articles OTHER